When it comes to finding the best burger in SoHo, New York City, Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer is a name that continues to rise above the competition. Nestled in the heart of one of NYC’s trendiest neighborhoods, Black Tap has built a reputation for crafting burgers that are as indulgent as they are innovative. As someone who typically enjoys veggie and vegan options, venturing into a place renowned for its classic American fare might seem out of the ordinary. But trust me, even the most committed plant-based foodies will be tempted to take a bite after exploring what Black Tap has to offer.
In this article, we’ll dive into what makes Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer a must-visit for anyone craving a sensational burger experience, and I’ll share my personal journey of discovering best burger in the heart of SoHo.
The Atmosphere: Classic Vibes with a Modern Twist
Before we even get to the food, it’s worth mentioning the atmosphere at Black Tap. Walking into the restaurant feels like stepping into a retro diner with a modern twist. The black-and-white tiled floors, neon signs, and vibrant street art create an inviting and energetic space. There’s something quintessentially “New York” about the vibe — it’s hip but unpretentious, making it a perfect spot for a casual lunch or dinner with friends.
The SoHo location, at 529 Broome Street, is right in the middle of one of the city’s most eclectic areas. With its prime location near shops, art galleries, and trendy spots, Black Tap offers a perfect refueling station after a day of exploring the neighborhood. The restaurant is known for attracting both locals and tourists alike, each eager to get a taste of their celebrated burgers.
The Burger Menu: A Culinary Playground
At Black Tap, the burgers are the star of the show. They’ve mastered the art of balancing traditional burger-making with inventive toppings and flavors. Their menu is filled with mouthwatering options, including their signature “All-American Burger” and the aptly named “Greg Norman Burger,” which features wagyu beef, blue cheese, and arugula.
For those like myself who lean towards a veggie-focused diet, the “Impossible Burger” at Black Tap is an absolute delight. Made with plant-based meat, the Impossible Burger packs the same juiciness and flavor of a classic burger but with a conscious twist. As someone who often seeks out vegan and veggie dining options, this burger impressed me. It’s hearty, flavorful, and comes with all the fixings you’d expect from a top-notch burger joint.
But the real allure of Black Tap is their attention to detail when it comes to flavor combinations. From the perfectly toasted buns to the crispy, golden fries served on the side, every bite feels like a celebration of American comfort food at its finest.
The Burger That Stole the Show: The Texan Burger
After perusing the menu, I settled on trying their popular “Texan Burger.” This bold creation features a juicy beef patty topped with cheddar cheese, crispy onion rings, bacon, and a barbecue sauce that brings everything together. The combination of textures and flavors in this burger was nothing short of spectacular. The smoky bacon paired with the sweet and tangy barbecue sauce hit all the right notes, while the onion rings added the perfect crunch.
In many ways, my experience discovering best burger at Black Tap was about more than just the meal — it was a celebration of indulgence. Even though I tend to shy away from meat, the Texan Burger was an exception worth making.
Over-the-Top Milkshakes: A Sweet Finish
Of course, a visit to Black Tap wouldn’t be complete without trying one of their famous milkshakes. Their over-the-top milkshakes have become a social media sensation, and for good reason. These towering desserts are loaded with toppings like cookies, cotton candy, sprinkles, and even full-sized slices of cake.
I opted for the “Cookies ‘N Cream Supreme,” which came topped with whipped cream, Oreos, and an ice cream sandwich. The shake was decadent and rich, providing the perfect counterbalance to the savory burger. While I typically avoid overly sweet treats, this milkshake was a fun, once-in-a-while indulgence that I couldn’t resist.
Secondary Intents: Why Black Tap is More Than Just Burgers
While Black Tap is undoubtedly a burger lover’s paradise, there’s more to this spot than meets the eye. Their diverse menu includes salads, chicken sandwiches, and even wings. Their craft beer selection is another major draw, with a rotating tap list that features local brews and well-known favorites.
If you’re looking for a spot to gather with friends for drinks, Black Tap’s full bar makes it a great choice. You can enjoy a cold beer or a cocktail while indulging in one of their famous burgers. For me, the variety on the menu ensured that even as a veggie enthusiast, I could find something that catered to my tastes, without sacrificing on flavor or experience.
Location, Location, Location: SoHo’s Culinary Scene
One of the things that makes Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer stand out is its location in SoHo. As a neighborhood that thrives on creativity, it’s no surprise that SoHo is home to some of the city’s most inventive culinary spots. Whether you’re in the area for its galleries or boutiques, a meal at Black Tap is the perfect way to cap off your visit.
For fellow foodies, SoHo is a playground of culinary delights. From high-end restaurants to hole-in-the-wall gems, this neighborhood offers something for everyone. Black Tap fits seamlessly into this scene, offering a unique dining experience that is both nostalgic and contemporary.
Final Thoughts: A Burger for Every Taste
As a New York-based writer with a deep love for veggie and vegan dining, I didn’t expect to fall head over heels for a place known for its meaty creations. But my experience at Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer in SoHo showed me that great food transcends dietary preferences. Whether you’re a die-hard meat eater or a plant-based enthusiast, Black Tap’s menu has something to offer everyone.
So, if you’re in SoHo and find yourself craving a truly exceptional burger, look no further than Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer. From their mouthwatering burgers to their whimsical milkshakes, this spot is an experience you won’t want to miss. In a city full of iconic eateries, Black Tap stands out as a must-visit for anyone discovering best burger in SoHo.